Page 243 - enav_27052016
P. 243

ENAV S.p.A. Financial Statement

                                         Litigation risks
                                         Litigation of a fiscal, administrative, civil and labour nature is followed by the
                                         competent functions of ENAV, which for the preparation of these financial
                                         statements have drawn up a complete and exhaustive description of the various civil,
                                         administrative and labour law proceedings. The Company has carried out a precise
                                         assessment of the risk of an adverse outcome in these proceedings, from which the
                                         need emerged to prudently set up specific provisions for those disputes in which
                                         an adverse outcome is considered probable and is reasonably quantifiable. In those
                                         cases where an adverse outcome is only considered possible, no specific provisions
                                         were recognized, in accordance with the accounting standards used to prepare the
                                         financial statements.
                                         At the present time it is not considered that the conclusion of the outstanding
                                         disputes will lead to significant costs for the Company other than the amounts
                                         provided for this purpose at 31 December 2015.

                                    Litigation abroad

                                         This case, dating back some time and still pending in the investigation phase at the
                                         Court of Buenos Aires, refers to the claim for damages from the failure to pay for the
                                         rendering of services allegedly provided by a consultant in the context of a mandate
                                         conferred by the Company on 1 June 2001 to establish business relations with
                                         Argentine institutions relating to the introduction of a civil air traffic control system
                                         into the country. No provision has been made as this is not deemed a probable risk
                                         by ENAV’s lawyers.

                                    Litigation in Italy

                                         Proceedings for debt recovery from suppliers and airport management companies.
                                         Legal action initiated regarding cases pending against suppliers and airport
                                         management companies that are insolvent, bankrupt or under other insolvency
                                         procedures continue. These refer to debts that it was not possible to recover using
                                         out-of-court procedures. Some of these positions have been written-down.

                                    Litigation in respect of suppliers

                                         These disputes refer mainly to opposing legal claims from suppliers or contractors
                                         that the Company deems to be unfounded (regarding, for example, alleged credits
                                         on invoices or price reviews, or requests for damages or claims for damages on
                                         challenged tender documents), or to recover the higher costs and/or damages that
                                         the Company incurred due to breaches by suppliers/contractors. If the outcome of
                                         the litigation should imply expenses, an allocation has been made in the appropriate
                                         risks and charges provision.

242 ENAV - Annual financial report 2015
   238   239   240   241   242   243   244   245   246   247   248